|

HORSE RACING
Horse racing is so popular in Hong Kong that it will be a long time before the
public accepts that there is cruelty inherent in racing horses and agrees to ban
it. Until recently it was banned in Mainland China. It is still banned in
Taiwan - but mainly for reasons concerning gambling.
For the 2002 Macau Jockey Club shooting
of horses, please refer to the E-mail List archives:
Go to
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/aapn/ Click on Messages; Search for
"Macau Jockey Club".
Or direct to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/aapn/message/1995
For stark photographs of the shooting, please write to:
info@aapn.org .
(click on thumbnail for sample photo)
The Sport of Bums
by Leith Babian
Look back at our
struggle for freedom,
Trace our present
day's strength to it's source;
And you'll find
that man's pathway to glory
Is strewn with
the bones of the horse.
~Author Unknown
No one ever thinks of the horse
Bart Cummings
There are many racing dynasties in Australia; Hayes,
Waterhouse, Cummings and Freedman are the best known stars of the show that is
horseracing. There are also many bit-players who do wondrous things with the
horse to turn them into elite athletes. Whenever the words ‘ horse trainer’ are
spoken, Australia’s own racing deity, Bart Cummings will be thought of as our
best. I only know him like most Australians, as the guy who seems to have been
around forever, who can turn average horses into Melbourne Cup heroes. He wins
Melbourne cups like they’re just another race. At the time of writing, he was up
to his 12th Cup, seven more than anyone else. He has also won all the
majors on the Australian east coast, often more than once. In
the book ‘Bart, the story of Bart Cummings’, Bruce Montgomerie tells how Bart
was bred to be a champion. His father and uncle were successful trainers. His
father Jim trained Melbourne Cup winner, Comic Court, in 1950.
Notably, Bart Cummings’ whole philosophy is based around
long term planning, kindness and patience with horses. This philosophy was
handed down from his father. Bart always relates his admiration of his father as
a horseman and says modestly of his own success that he is just continuing his
father’s work. One thing that I’ve heard Bart Cummings speak of regularly is the
direction of the racing and breeding industry. While he is not the rant and rave
type, he has been relatively vocal about ‘softer boned’, imported stock with
which we have since been inundated. Among other things, he was trying to
preserve the dying ‘home-breeds’ who had perhaps adapted better to Australian
conditions. Compounding the problem is that we now have more racing of two-year
olds and with a focus on sprinting. Nobody listened to Bart.
Each Spring we see headlines when horses from England and
Ireland arrive to race on our ‘hard’ tracks. Their connections like ‘cut in the
ground’. Consequently, we are irrigating our tracks more than ever. Not too
many years back, tracks rated ‘Fast’ and ‘Good’ were the ideal. Nowadays, they
make trainers whine. It is clear that young horses with immature bones don’t
cope physically regardless of where they’re bred. Now all tracks have to be
presented with a ‘dead’ surface for fear of horses jarring up. When tracks are
presented dead, they are damaged more easily. Damaged tracks become uneven and
next thing you know, there’s a ‘track bias’ and jockeys start scouting away from
the fence looking for even ground. There’s also the risk of uneven, gouged out
tracks twisting and wrenching delicate joints. As a consequence, we now have the
racing industry spending millions of dollars on the research and development of
synthetic tracks, some of which fail miserably.
Another Sydney (via QLD) trainer, John Size, was a racing
revelation. At one point in his racing life, he’d wound up the stables in
Brisbane and was having an indefinite break from training. He was like so many
that don’t last too long away from the horse. John had been working as a
professional punter in Sydney but kept saying he missed the horses. So back he
came and when he did get his momentum going in Sydney he was having so much
success that he could not accommodate all the horses that were being sent to
him. “I’ve put the training fees up but the horses keep coming so I’ve had to
get more stables at the showground!” He was hot and his horses were racing in
great form. Testimony to his rare ability was the fact that he was quickly head
hunted by the Hong Kong Jockey Club, the Mecca of racing and he hasn’t come
back.
Most importantly, John Size works very hard on his success.
When he resumed his career in Sydney he started off with a very small team. He
placed his horses particularly well, that is in the weakest company possible
thus giving them the best chance of winning. Swimming his horses twice as long
as was then the norm, walking them thrice daily, both before and after trackwork
and again in the afternoon was also a big factor. This may not sound terribly
revolutionary but with limited staff some trainers are charging a small fortune
yet have horses that don’t even get out of the box for a walk in the afternoon.
Athletes, especially equine aren’t supposed to be confined for such long
periods. The other notable John Size innovation was that he used barrier trials
to bring his horses to peak fitness. Some of the horses would get three trials
before a race which was unheard of. I was horrified when a racing administrator
from Racing NSW complained that too many horses trialing were detrimental to the
size of race fields in Sydney, his argument being that those horses in trials
could have been in races bolstering numbers. It is expensive to trial horses but
the benefits far outweigh the expense. Most importantly the longevity of the
race horse is more likely if it is as fit as possible by trialling as many times
as necessary before racing. Thus owners get more value for money. And most
importantly, horses are much better educated and prepared using trials than
races where they are under far more pressure both physically and mentally. A
horse can go to barrier trials and have an easy time without stress. A couple
more good experiences in subsequent trials and you have a more relaxed athlete
on race day.
When John Size started to win so many races, many other
trainers adopted his methods, even leading ones. It was one of the fastest rises
through the training ranks in the tough Sydney environment ever seen; he set new
benchmarks in training racehorses. The thing that Bart Cummings and John Size
have in common is the foundation training.
The general public’s knowledge of the racing industry is
limited outside of the headline-acts. The reality is that it is very hard to
survive as a trainer especially on the country circuit. Back in the first year
of my jockey’s apprenticeship at Coffs Harbour I had to wait eight weeks for my
boss, Chris to pay me. That’s how long it took him to get paid from some of his
clients. I was never concerned because boarding with Chris and his partner
Angela I didn’t really need much money, I was practically part of the family.
With my savings and any slings from grateful owners when I won on their horses,
I had more than enough money. I’d have done it all for nothing and sometimes
that’s what my rides deserved. That same year, I had to lend two trainers money
to pay-up for their runners because they were so broke, otherwise they wouldn’t
have been able to start their horses.
Jockeys
Illiterate little people who hit horses
Clive Robertson
Just as racehorses are athletes, so too are the jockeys.
It takes a great deal of fitness to ride around a dozen horses each morning.
Having said that, you could ride trackwork all of your life and if you had to
ride in an actual race you’d still be exhausted by the home turn, it’s sports
specific. It takes another level of fitness to ride a horse in a race, no matter
if that race lasts for 1000 metres or 3000 metres, let alone hurdle and
steeplechase racing. Riding in a race at The Gold Coast one afternoon the field
started to sprint on the home turn. I could hear snorting and snuffing behind
and thought, Wow, that horse sounds terrible but it was gaining on me! As
the sound got closer, I looked around and it was the famous Mel
Schumacher on his comeback ride, red faced and gasping
for air.
One of the first things that every jockey is told is that
the whip is the last resort.
I remember my very first barrier trial back in Coffs
Harbour. All the trainers were happy that I could use the whip. I was happy that
the trainers were happy; it meant that I’d get rides from them. The best advice
came from Rex Kelly, then a jockey who snarled at me after the trial and told me
where to shove my whip. I always gave Rex a wide berth thereafter. Too busy
dreaming of future success, I couldn’t even steer properly let alone wield a
whip. I missed Rex Kelly’s point completely.
Come race day people want to see you ride like a demon.
There are always a few guys around known for their very strong whip riding.
They must be really trying to win. At one point I used to model myself on a
leading jockey called Gavan Duffy. He was well known for his short length of
stirrup and his great vigour. I had more than one trainer and an owner tell me
that they had actually wanted Duffy as their first choice of rider as they were
giving me my instructions. “He can be a dog, this bastard, you get stuck into
him as soon as you straighten”; or “the more you hit her the better she goes.”
I’ll give them Duffy, I’d say to myself
I hitched my stirrup irons up a few notches and gave the
horse the flogging they wanted, and it won. They were ecstatic but the horse
would have won anyway. While it is misguided, there is pressure on jockeys to be
aggressive with the whip. Every few years, the issue of whips has come up but
nothing ever changed until 2009. The whips we’ve been using hurt and leave welt
marks. Horses respond to whips but it’s more by association, rhythm and the
sound of the cracking. The cracking sound comes from the two pieces of leather
on the end of the whip slapping against one another. There is no need to add
pain to the mix. In fact, whips cause some horses to lose concentration and
galloping rhythm. Often horses that are finishing a race off powerfully lose
momentum as soon as they are struck. So they can be a handicap, especially in
the wrong hands.
I once asked a steward about the overuse of whips and his
main concern was that if restrictions came in someone would have to count how
many times jockeys were hitting the horses. Naturally that would be a pain in
the arse. Perhaps it was the way I posed the question that was flawed. The best
idea thus far has been the introduction of a kinder, padded whip. The ARB, in a
media release, announced that ‘The best scientific advice available to us says
that padded whips do not inflict pain or injury, and that is the outcome we
want.’ It was a momentous occasion. As usual in the insular racing industry
there was initial reluctance to change and some of the feedback was reported in
the media. Some of the jocks quoted in the newspaper said of the old whips “It
don’t hurt ‘em”. They must have been the lucky ones, who have never been hit by
another jockey in the heat of battle, but I doubt that. Perhaps their memory is
short also, it bloody hurts all right. I was unfortunate enough to have been in
Gavan Duffy’s firing line at Doomben one afternoon the bruising was there for a
week. Another leading jockey said in protest “you have to get the best out of
the horse”; he may as well have said “I really need to be able to hurt the
fuckers and I can’t do that with these padded whips”.
In their defence, there were a couple of jockeys who said
that they wouldn’t mind if the kinder whips were introduced. A few jockeys,
after being interviewed by the press said that they would accept the padded
whips. They sensibly reasoned that if everyone were using them it would be an
even playing field. Left to the racing community the changes would never have
occurred. Giving the responsibility to some jockeys where whips are concerned is
like appointing Mike Tyson as relationship advisor. Being a male dominated
sport, men tend to get very attached to their rods. Eventually, the ARB bowed to
the will of the community and made the padded whip compulsory. Appropriately the
date that the new laws commenced is August 1st 2009, the birthday of
all southern hemisphere horses. The padded whips still hurt but not as much as
the variety used before. A further concession for the horse is that there is now
a limit on the amount of times that a horse can be hit but in the heat of the
moment, jockeys forget the rules. Fines and suspensions have been dished out for
whip rule breaches but the various racing authorities have lacked consistency in
their interpretations causing much angst among jockeys, trainers and horse
owners.
The racing stewards have been unfairly lumped with the
blame for the problems arising from the whip rule changes. They have been put in
a difficult situation. After a race there is immense pressure to declare
‘correct weight’ within a mere few minutes, this is the job of stewards. Winning
punters want their money. The whip issue has increased the workload of stewards
especially on already hectic racedays. Are we a step closer to banning whips
altogether?
With international experience Aussie jocks seem to have
embraced many overseas styles; that is, British, American and European and
developed an Australian hybrid. At the core of this new style is that the rider
has their foot only partially inserted in the stirrup. Most ride on the ball of
the foot or even on their toes. Some have grasped it better than others. It can
be balanced, pretty and aerodynamic. Others have stuck with the old way. Some
are trying to have an each way bet by incorporating some of the old style into
the new by kicking. I’ve seen top jockeys lose control of their mounts and it
has cost them races. Their feet can fall out or get knocked out of the stirrups.
It has even been banned for apprentices just starting out due to accidents. The
first person I saw in Australia who mastered the American style is Sydney’s
Daniel Beasley. I was a trackwork rider at Randwick when he started out but
watching him I noticed that unlike other jockeys he didn’t change his style mid
stream. He started out with that particular style and stuck to it. Australia’s
best jockey Darren Beadman has not adopted the new style. Before he returned to
Hong Kong Beadman had been riding rings around Australia’s best for a decade. Of
course this is all just part of the evolution of riding styles. The next
generation will probably all ride in this fashion. After a Hong Kong stint
charismatic jockey Glenn Boss came back riding in the toe-in style. In 2008 he
produced two daredevil rides in the 2008 Golden Slipper and then again in the
Doncaster Handicap a week later. I can only put it down to his attitude and
sheer will to win. Bossy shouldered his horse into a very reasonable position
after missing the start and being a clear last in the mad scramble of the
Slipper. In the Doncaster Handicap he used his horse again to make room where
there didn’t seem to be any in the home straight. The Bossy siren went off again
and he came through to win. He was the difference between a win and a luckless
defeat. The irrepressible Glenn Boss kept his stirrups on both occasions. Rider
safety seems to be the main reason behind the popularity of the ‘toe in’ style,
the idea being that if the foot isn’t inserted all the way into the stirrup you
reduce the chances of getting caught up in it. I’ve heard some horrific stories
of trackwork riders being dragged for hundreds of meters or thrown over a fence
while one foot was still caught – it’s every rider’s nightmare.
In recent years rider safety vests were introduced. While
it seems that some people have become very attached to the safety vest (it is
called a safety vest after all) my concern, like many others is that the vests
restrict flexibility and stop a fallen jockey from gradually rolling to a stop.
I’ve seen jockeys that appear to have been speared into the turf taking most of
the force on their spine and head/neck. Some jockeys expressed similar concerns
about the safety vest that eventually prompted a 14-page web
report by the RIRDC focused only on neck injuries (rirdc.gov.au).
Titled “Assessment of protective jockey vests” the report shows the number of
neck injury compensation claims through the Thoroughbred Racing Board (TRB),
which resulted in more than one year off work-
In the four
years prior to safety vests the number of compensation claims was 26
In the four
years since of safety vests the number of compensation claims was 41
The report
concludes that the current safety vests do not increase the risk of neck
injuries. It went on to make this recommendation-
“It is
recommended that consideration be given to the establishment of a national
jockey
injury database consisting of reports of falls, the use and specifications of
protective
equipment such as skull caps and vests, details of any injuries sustained and
the
circumstances of the fall, including where possible a video record. “
The recommendation seems to be the best thing to come of
the report. Otherwise it has discounted many other factors including injured
ex-jockey Norm Waymouth’s concerns about ‘rolling naturally’ pre-safety vests.
It did not find that vests have reduced the number of deaths or the severity of
injuries because that was not the focus of the report. Surely those figures are
available? What use other than psychological or an attempt to fulfil OH&S
requirements is a vest that does not increase the chances of saving a life or
just as important, quality of life for the survivors of the worst falls?
All of my falls occurred in the days before safety vests
and the ‘toe in’ riding style. I had five race falls in my short career and was
lucky to walk away from all of them, if not out of hospital on the same day. In
some of the falls I rolled for what seemed like an eternity. Sometimes watching
the replay it looked as if horses galloping over me were kicking me along. I
don’t remember hitting the ground in four of my falls, it all happens very
quickly and the next thing you feel is the seemingly endless rolling. I couldn’t
bring myself to watch such replays more than once, if at all unless it was
absolutely necessary for a stewards inquiry. While happy to be proven wrong by a
comprehensive study, I am of the belief that it was rolling to a stop that saved
me from serious injury. If I could ride again, I would rather take my chances
without the safety vests but I wouldn’t be allowed to.
Turn of the Century Racing
“You can make whatever you do an art form”
Viveka Turnbull-Hocking
The good news is that we started the new century with some
of our best horses ever. If I could come back in another life with the choice of
being any trainer, it would not be as a multiple group winning, or premiership
winning trainer. It would be as Joe Janiak, so that I could travel the globe
with my world-class athlete. There’s never a dull moment in racing and we take
for granted the great horses and personalities that come and go each season.
From humble beginnings in Queanbeyan, NSW one horse has beaten our best
sprinters in every Australian state before taking on the world’s best and
beating them in Great Britain, Singapore and Japan. His connections have had a
magical ride on the back of this $1400 reject giving hope to those waiting for
the good one to come along. Jockey Jay Ford got his ‘good horse’. He is young
enough to still be around for another. Now world-renowned are Takeover Target
and trainer Joe Janiak. The book is out and the movie is coming. In an era where
good horses seem to be here one day and forgotten the next, Takeover Target
competed at the top level over six seasons!
Before Takeover Target came along racing the new millennium
had been dominated by two horses. The horses Northerly and Sunline set new
benchmarks in fighting spirit and winning consistently at the top level. Thus
they have brought fame and fortune to everyone connected with them. From the far
reaches of our racing precincts, Sunline from New Zealand and Northerly from WA,
they were destined to clash in spring. Each horse won The W S Cox Plate, the
‘heavyweight championship’ of Australasian racing, not once but twice among many
of our other most coveted races. I was lucky enough to be in the stand for the
2001 Cox Plate when Sunline was shooting for number three. Sunline always raced
in the lead, where there is nowhere to hide. It was my first time at Moonee
Valley, such a small track you get a close-up of the action. Sunline looked to
have the lead comfortably but Northerly wore her down in the brutal final 200
Metres. A little 3-year-old colt called Viscount who had followed the great mare
all of the way was still there, jammed in between them as they slogged out the
finish with pushing and shoving aplenty. His effort was courageous just to hold
his ground. It wouldn’t have been at all surprising if his finishing position
had been elevated in the subsequent protest hearing. In the 2002 Cox Plate
Northerly stalked Sunline again before beating her easily.
The gutsy Northerly eventually retired due to a tendon
injury. How Sunline never succumbed to injury is unbelievable. The best mare I
ever saw, Sunline gave it her all every time she raced. Horses that try as hard
as Sunline rarely stand up to the physical pressure. She could do what very few
horses could do and that was to stretch her speed from 1200M to 2000M. One of
her most courageous efforts was in defeat. It was in a rich race, The Dubai Duty
Free, 1777 metres. Adding further merit to her performance was that she had to
acclimatise to a trip across the world to race on an unfamiliar dirt surface
before being constantly attacked in the lead. She still fought the opposition
off until the bitter end where she was conceding only a small margin. Any other
horse except perhaps the great Vo Rogue would have been spent by the home turn.
Sunline’s jockey Greg Childs retired not long after Sunline. Perhaps he knew the
odds against riding another ‘good one’ like her were astronomical.
When I was still a jockey at Southport I chased Vo Rogue
around a couple of times early in his career. He was a long, long way in front
by the time we reached the post. In fact sometimes he was making his way back to
scale. He had a habit of ducking out of the first left-hand gap that he saw
after the post whether his jockey was ready or not. Nobody could have known what
he’d go on to do. Vo Rogue’s progression to become one of Australia’s all time
greats was astounding. Ask people to name some of the best horses of the 80s and
90s and they’ll probably mention a few horses that saw a lot of Vo Rogue’s bum.
Jockey Cyrl Small deservedly got his ‘good horse’.
Just when the racing public was coming down from the highs
of Sunline and Northerly, along came another legend of the turf, Australia’s
greatest staying mare, Makybe Diva. That makes four of our best ever horses in
the first decade! Makybe Diva won many of Australia’s best races, The BMW
(formerly known as The Tancred Stakes), The Australian Cup and a Cox Plate. The
Diva is the only horse to win three Melbourne Cups, the worlds richest 3200
Metre event and Australia’s greatest sporting event. Three amazing feats of
navigation by jockey Glenn Boss certainly were a huge factor in Makybe Diva’s
Cups record. However, as the charismatic jockey said in post race interviews,
“she seemed bottomless”; that is, when most horses are reaching for the
nebuliser at the top of the straight, she just took another breath before
breezing past them. If George Moore had a whistle, then Glenn Boss had a siren
because it seemed like the other horses were pulling over when she flew by.
In recent years the Irish gallopers have won a couple of
Melbourne Cups. UK horses have been unlucky not to win more. I dare say that if
they had used Australian based jockeys they would have won more. I don’t mean
any disrespect but the race is 3200M under Australian conditions, which are far
different from UK racing. You really want a rider who’s at least been around
Australasian tracks. I will go as far as to say that they should have won a
couple more cups than they did. Let’s face it, it is the Melbourne Cup and
they’ve come from the other side of the world. If you get it wrong it’s not like
you can make up for it next week. In 2006 the Japanese brought two horses over
called Delta Blues and Eye Popper. They ran great lead ups in the Caulfield Cup
and went on to totally dominate in the Melbourne Cup with only a head between
them at the finish. It was an awesome display of Japanese superiority. The
Japanese have spent a fortune building their racing industry and have become a
racing superpower. After their Cup Quinella they promised to come back in
numbers. Quarantine problems have kept them out of Australia since 2006, due to
Equine Influenza (EI).
The 2009 Melbourne Cup was one the great Irish jokes. In a
Melbourne Cup first, three horses from the famous Aiden O’Brien of Ballydoyle
stable went out and created a big early lead. It was as if they were in a race
completely of their own. One of the three, Septimus, was a heavily backed
favourite for the Cup and being touted as Europe’s best stayer. In the press
leading up to the Cup everyone seemed to think that the Cup was as good as over
before it began, such was the reputation of Septimus. All three were spent at
the home turn and dropped right out of contention to finish 18th, 20th
and 21st. Their jockeys and trainer having totally underestimated and
misjudged the race they went back to Ireland with tired and sore horses. It’ll
be as funny to them as it was to us in no less than two years. One thing is for
sure, Ballydoyle is a racing giant, they will be back and they will get better
with each visit. Considering Australia’s focus on two year old sprinters in
recent years, I don’t see the trend of foreign horses winning our great race
ending anytime soon. Bart Cummings saved us from The Cup going to a ‘pommie’
trainer in 2008. In winning his 12th Melbourne Cup he is the thin
green and gold line defending our great race.
A quick buck mentality means we concentrate too much on
racing immature, sprinting horses and don’t have much left to offer when it
comes to our classics and great staying events. They’re all knackered and that’s
just the start of the bad news. This has been the most alarming change in racing
in recent years; put it down to capitalism unchecked in an industry unchecked.
The detrimental effects of pushing immature horses are far reaching. In recent
years Australia has progressively promoted the mad scamper of frightened babies
that is two year-old racing. This is where the problem of attrition originates
and the marketing from the breeding industry in favour of ‘early comers’ is
relentless. The prize money for the Golden Slipper is ridiculously high. They’re
talking about closing in on the $5 million mark in the near future. WHY?
Surely this sort of money is better spread throughout the industry. Run by the
Sydney Turf Club (STC); The Golden Slipper was introduced to rival the
Australian Jockey Club’s (AJC) big races. They could easily make the Golden
Slipper for older horses. Australian race clubs also could do away with rivalry
altogether and co-operate instead as some clubs are struggling to survive.
Breeders openly state that they aren’t interested in stayers. The ‘product’ must
be ‘precocious’; two of racing’s current buzzwords, along with ‘Jarred up’. We
now have a situation in Australia where quality older horses are scarce. It is
the selling of Australia’s racing soul.
From time to time, various influential people in the
industry have expressed concern about racing two-year-olds. Darren Beadman once
wrote in an article for the Sydney Morning Herald that racing two-year olds had
too many detrimental effects. He suggested that their racing careers could be
delayed to take pressure off them. Well meaning trainers have also voiced their
concern from time to time but they usually only say it once. Becoming too
outspoken could be bad for business of any trainer of jockey.
The physical impact on the horse has been well documented.
They aren’t fully-grown and mature until about five years old. For the layperson
you could liken the demands on young horses to prepping your 5 year-old kid to
play sport at a national level. What sort of a crippled nut case do you think
you’d end up with under that kind of physical and emotional pressure? The mental
aspect is less documented. People falsely accept that racehorses are flighty. At
the races when a horse plays up in the parade ring or becomes agitated in the
barrier stalls people think “Oh, that’s just thoroughbreds for you”. They simply
don’t realise that what you see on raceday could just be the result of
oversight, poor diet, neglect and sometimes, sheer stupidity all adding to the
horses stress level. The evidence is on display daily. Go and watch a horserace
in Australia on any day of the week and you will see behavioural problems.
Multiple broadcasts within seconds of each other put pressure on the human who
in turn puts pressure on the horse. Putting pressure on a nervous and tuned up
racehorse behind the barriers on race day is a recipe for disaster. Everyone is
in a hurry, the barrier staff Australia-wide are under pressure to get the
horses loaded and away at a specific time. All in all, about 1-2 minutes is
allocated to getting the average size field of horses into the barriers and
away. So when a horse chucks a wobbly, there goes your schedule. In another
state, they’re holding up a race where the horses could be waiting in the
barriers also about to chuck a wobbly. Race days are not the time for educating
fractious horses. It is nothing short of tragic that as well educated as horse
people now are, you still see horses going crazy in the barriers at the races.
The barrier stalls are a dangerous place to be stuck with a petrified animal of
around 500 kilograms or more. An animal thrashing around in a confined space and
smashing itself to death against a steel structure is very disturbing. And
sadly, that’s the ‘product’ coming off our line in Australia.
I worked for a big city stable a few years back and scores
of yearlings came into training. Only a couple stood up to race as two
year-olds. The rest had heat in their joints and shins which ended their
campaign. I’ve seen first hand how most don’t cope physically and mentally with
the training required of them. Some of them never came back. The staff watch
these horses grow as they go through the learning process of what being a
racehorse is all about. We are relieved when a baby that isn’t coping is sent
back out, we assume to the paddock. The horses come to the stables innocent and
curious. Some are timid, some are friendly and others are boisterous just like
pre-school kids. Still, they are delicate. Our hands are always on their legs
feeling for heat or any abnormality. From the day they are foaled, someone is
caring for them as if they are handling a precious human child. This goes on
through the stages of breaking-in and into training. After a gallop or two you
start to notice little changes in their behaviour as some cope better than
others. By the time that they have had a trial there is a definite losing of
that innocence that they had when they first arrived, generally referred to as
sourness. Some may not even make it that far and have already gone back out.
Staff are busy and don’t dwell on these things. If they don’t come back there
are always others to look after. Their name might pop up in the paper in another
racing precinct or it may not. When they do come back it is like seeing your
adopted kid come back, hopefully big and strong. It’s wonderful to have a horse
come back to you next preparation and to help it along its career. You know when
a strapper’s favourite horse is back. There’s a fresh enthusiasm in their work.
Almost all racing stables train at racetracks where they
have a limited amount of time to get all their horses to the track. Usually
between 4:30 AM and 8AM. The bigger the team the more pressure on everyone to
work quickly, pressure, which inevitably transfers to the horses. Do we really
work ridiculous hours so that the daily maintenance work can commence on the
tracks? So many people rushing around highly sensitive animals so that someone
can come to work at a sensible hour to ride around on a tractor. Addressing
this single issue could solve most of our problems and increase staff retention.
Trainers need the facilities to practice the art of
training rather than being forced to go through the motions as quickly as
possible. The best advice I was ever given was by a respected old horse breaker.
As a trainer, in my 30s, I knew that I hadn’t had enough exposure to yearlings
at the breaking in stage. This is because people like Theo Green protected us
from educating babies. He firmly believed that it was not the job of apprentice
jockeys to be breaking in horses. Going on to being a jockey and a trackwork
rider, I didn’t get enough exposure to breaking in or starting young horses. I
thought I’d left it too late in life to start but asked the breaker for some
work experience. Making time for this on my weekends, he tolerated me helping
out and asking questions. The most valuable thing the breaker imparted was;
“When the horse feels that it is under too much pressure it stops thinking and
may panic. If we’re going to alleviate that pressure we mustn’t stop thinking.”
There is an opportunity here for breakers or pre-trainers to be given the job of
spending the extra time on these horses to alleviate the pressure. A lot of
trouble would be avoided later on as well as the sanity and longevity of the
horse. Champion Sydney trainer Gai Waterhouse has hired horse people from the
USA in the past. These so-called ‘horse whisperers’ sole purpose was to acquaint
the horse with the barrier stalls. This highlights that there is a problem in
Australian racing that needs serious attention.
Would we attract new participants to the industry if we
were seen to be, and indeed were more humane instead of treating our equine
athletes like a conveyer belt product with built in obsolescence? Should we
strategise for longevity in the animal rather than being suppliers for
knackeries with our broken young horses? If ever there was an incentive for
racing mature horses, it is that they are great for racing in many ways. Our
classic races need them and the real crowd pullers, like Sunline, Northerly,
Makybe Diva and Takeover Target drew enormous attention to racing, they bring
people back to the track. All of the people associated with Makybe Diva, owner,
trainers and jockey, noted that she was given time to mature and got better and
stronger every season. The same could be argued in the case of Sunline,
Northerly and the evergreen Takeover Target. He was Australia’s best sprinter
and possibly world’s best sprinter when he was nine years old! When you look
back at Australia’s greats, they are the seasoned campaigners. In Sunline,
Makybe Diva, Northerly and Takeover Target we had four of our best ever.
As great as they were, Sunline and Northerly only highlight
the magnificence of the greatest horse seen on Australian tracks for
generations. He is the late champion Kingston Town. Everyone experiences
something unparalleled in his or her life, perhaps something freakish that stays
with you forever. In my life I was fortunate enough to watch Kingston Town race.
The spectacular looking black athlete won an unprecedented three W S Cox Plates.
His most ardent fans hope the record will never be equalled. When I was
thirteen, one of the Barker boys took me to see him at one of Smith’s Sydney
stables. The King had won a race on my thirteenth birthday. I gave him a pat and
a cuddle, and the cheeky bugger gave me a harmless nip. It’s close to the
highlight of my racing life.
One of the happiest days of my young life was when I rode
my first double. It was the same day that Kingston Town ran second in the 1982
Melbourne Cup. From the jockeys’ room at Coffs Harbour, I heard the crowd roar
and a trembling underfoot when he sprinted to the lead. Even people who didn’t
bet on him still cheered Kingston Town. He seemed home and hosed and I’d just
ridden my first double, everything in the world was working out as it should.
Then the caller mentioned the eventual winner Gurner’s Lane challenging. It
didn’t matter that Gurner’s Lane was a great horse who was about to complete a
rare Caulfield/Melbourne Cups double nor that Mick Dittman was one of our most
respected jockeys. They were the villains. There was long, mournful silence
everywhere and my happiest day turned into one of the most disappointing. In
horseracing, second doesn’t mean much. I’ve seen some wonderful runners-up over
the years chasing the same good horses in our best races. They never get a
mention once their name is out of the formguide. Kingston Town was our most
discussed runner up such was the public adoration of him.
As Australia’s first millionaire racehorse you had to see
‘The King’ to believe his freakish ability. I watched him coast home in some of
his Randwick and Rosehill wins to standing ovations from the awestruck crowds.
I’d never seen people respond to a horse like they did to this one, he’d reduce
many fans to tears. Sometimes when The King shot well clear in the straight, it
was just as awesome to look around and up into the stands to see the crowd’s
reaction. People would duly stand as one and the applause would start at the top
of the straight. The race was over. The applause would continue as Johnston
trotted him back to scale and didn’t stop until The King left the enclosure. We
couldn’t get enough of Kingston Town and he didn’t disappoint, winning 21 times
on Sydney tracks. The King was raced for five racing seasons despite
interruptions with serious injuries. He raced from distances of 1200M to 3200M
and back again and he answered every call with the sort of versatility and
acceleration I’ve never seen before or since. His finishing sprint was what made
him different from any other horse. It was the same over 1200 metres as it was
over 3200 metres. It got that way that nobody ever expected him to lose and in
Sydney, he hardly ever did. Yet he only did as much as his jockey made him do in
a race, he would relax as soon as he felt his jockey relax. Or was he just smart
and looking after his dicky legs? Fact is that some of Kingston Town’s most
memorable victories were performed carrying chronic injuries that would have
ended the careers of most horses. Furthermore they were in Melbourne where it
appeared he was always uncomfortable racing in the anti-clockwise direction. Not
only did he beat the best horses around in both the main venues of Australian
racing, i.e. Sydney and Melbourne but he won in Brisbane and Perth as well, at
the end of a hard racing campaign.
The very fortunate connections were the Hains, who owned
The King, Sydney’s most successful trainer, TJ Smith and Malcolm Johnston, the
jockey for most of his wins. However, due to suspensions, Ron Quinton and Peter
Cook rode The King in the latter two of his Cox Plate wins. Johnston was famous
for his perfect seat on a horse and there’s never been a prettier sight in
racing than Malcolm Johnston and Kingston Town in full flight. Malcolm will go
to his grave feeling like the chosen one who got to partner The King. All
jockeys dream about winning a Melbourne Cup or a Cox Plate. Nobody expects to be
lucky enough to ride a Kingston Town or a Makybe Diva. Conversely, nobody could
know the disappointment that poor Malcolm felt when he saw his old pal win two
of his three Cox Plates without him or the pain of running second in a Melbourne
Cup that he should have won. Through Kingston Town, Malcolm felt the ecstasy and
the gutting agony, a price any jockey would pay. For people associated with the
greats it must be like experiencing death when racing careers end.
Jockey Peter Cook was the human equivalent of Kingston Town
where freakish ability was concerned. Peter Cook’s riding talent, it is said, is
a gift that can not be passed on, i.e. you either have it or you don’t. Being an
optimist, I don’t believe this. If we’re ever going to discover another Cookie,
it may be now that the whip rules have been tempered. Peter Cook had a great
seat but most of all he seemed to be able to get horses to try their hearts out
for him while seemingly doing nothing. He was beautifully balanced and super
cool in a race. That was his trademark. With his rare use of the whip he was
living proof that horses don’t need to be flogged to do their best. His was a
tough era; there were many, many great jockeys around during his time. Like
Kingston Town, racing statistics do not do him justice and like The King, I’ve
yet to see another like him, not even close. Watching Peter Cook’s historic ride
on Kingston Town in his last Cox Plate victory is like watching a blockbuster
film condensed into a couple of minutes. I’ve never seen Cookie so out of
character on a horse. Perhaps he is mortal after all and felt the grand final
nerves. Kingston Town was loafing right from the jump and Cookie harassed and
terrorised him into competing. Under the whip from the start, bustled nearly all
of the way and whipped again before the sprint in the straight everyone
including the race caller had written the King off (It took a lot more
convincing of Victorians that Kingston Town was a champion. They used to call
him a “Sydney Champion”). Victorian caller Bill Collins sounded arrogant as he
said those words, the ones he wished he could take right back; “Kingston Town
can’t win!” No sooner were these words uttered than Kingston Town changed onto
his correct leading leg. It seemed he’d been saving his battle-weary legs until
it counted. Once he changed stride, the famous sprint seemed to magically
reappear and the race was over. Cookie even put the whip away in the home
straight. It is most fitting that our best jockey won our best race on our best
horse.
The
Product
' 84% of breeders own racehorses'
Thoroughbred Breeders Australia
Australia is a country blessed with many gifted horsepeople.
We like to pass ourselves off as a nation of horse lovers as was seen by our
impressive display of horsemanship at the opening of the 2000 Olympics. In
racing you always hear people getting romantic about how wonderful horses are,
especially in the winner’s enclosure. The media shows people gushing about their
horses and attributing human qualities to them - ‘brilliant fighting spirit; not
just a horse but part of the family; great desire to win; courageous; tough as
teak; a real gentleman; a showman; a real lady; great personality; a pleasure to
train; the people’s horse, I love everyone, etc. ’
Next time you see a winner coming back to scale after a big
race, watch how the connections kiss, hug, cry, dance around and declare their
undying love for the horse. Tears also flow freely when a good horse breaks
down.
Increasing exposure of the racing industry has brought
horse welfare to the forefront of mainstream media. USA racing received bad
publicity in 2009 due to the relatively laissez faire use of drugs and recent
breakdowns of some of their best young horses, Eight Bells and Kentucky Derby
winner Big Brown. Also in 2009 public debate raged in Australia about whether
racehorses should be whipped. In June, 2002 the headline in
the South China Morning Post read
‘Macau Horse Slaughter Exposed’.
This was a story about how horses are shot when no longer profitable. It
resulted in a slinging match between the two major race clubs of Macau and Hong
Kong who also shoot their ex racers. For the next three weeks the South China
Morning Post contained follow-ups as well as letters with offers from people all
over the world to take in the horses and give them a home. There was also and
expose` on television showing the Australian Veterinarian shooting healthy but
unprofitable horses. I wonder, when he was studying at University if this was
how he envisioned his future self. While he was the one holding the gun, the
Veterinary community in general has been deafeningly silent on the plight of our
juvenile thoroughbreds. Many Vets make a very good living from the racing
industry.
Currently in Australia, the animal
libbers have focused most of their attention to the jumps industry but the
entire industry is under increasing scrutiny. Media reports and even Web
sites pop up occasionally highlighting the fact that the racing and breeding
industry have not implemented any strategies for the improvement of horse’s
quality of life and potentially saving them from the knackery. The expensive
potential champ who doesn’t make it is suddenly tagged with non-human
characteristics; “What a dog.” The reality is that there are a myriad of
possible reasons horses don’t make it but the industry has not focussed on
these. If they don’t stand up to the pressure we, “Just piss them off and get
another one. It costs just as much to feed a good one as a bad one” etc. The
unprofitable one can find itself at a sale yard where the dogger will be waiting
for a bargain.
The solution seems obvious so why does the lot of
racehorses seem more perilous than ever?
a)
Everyone’s too busy to save slow horses
b)
Thought they all got a good home somewhere
c)
The alternative is not a nice thing to dwell on
d)
All of the above
Many people think that racehorses are not much good at
other pursuits in life outside of racing. Some think that racehorses don’t have
a good temperament, or even that they are fiery or mad. This is simply untrue.
The many ex-racehorses that are recruited into the police force highlight the
intelligence of thoroughbreds. It takes a cooperative and reliable animal to be
a police horse; human lives are at stake! Racehorses can be retrained any
horseperson worth their salt would agree with this. You would be amazed at what
a change of routine and especially diet can do for an ex racehorse.
Thoroughbreds do extremely well in other pursuits such as dressage, eventing and
show jumping just to name a few. The point is that the racing stuff can be
unlearned. The racing authorities Hong Kong and now Macau make generous
financial contributions to owners who want to save their animals from the
bullet. Local riding schools take some of racing’s unwanted. The greyhound
racing industry in Australia has shown initiative in marketing greyhounds for
other uses after their racing days are over. What has the Australian
thoroughbred industry done? We mass-produce thoroughbreds and we injure them
physically and mentally. It follows that we are responsible for giving them a
fair go at living a full life where they can be retrained. In Australia I only
know of one organisation totally devoted to ex racehorses. A kind soul in
Victoria, after working in racing stables, took it upon herself to start a
charity for ex racehorses. This one saviour and her colleagues only highlight
the glaring meanness that taints the whole racing scene. If we were all judged
by the same criteria we use for disposing of our horses, there would be quite a
few less human stomachs to worry about filling.
Being out of the game, I got to experience another way of
life that racing life doesn’t allow time for. I was able to see how our sport is
perceived from the other side. Meeting people for the first time at social
gatherings I would hope they not ask about my background or occupation.
Inevitably, the question comes up. I’ve spoken to people who don’t know the
first thing about horseracing but think “It’s all rigged”. At the very least,
they don’t take us seriously. Some think that horse racing is a haven for ‘black
money’, race fixing, steroids, knobblers and shifty, illiterate characters that
talk funny. Others think that we are just plain cruel. Even people from other
horse pursuits raise an eyebrow. They are part right, to a point but I’d sooner
invest my money in racing than the stock market, racing is more honest.
Sure, there are some who have always worked with racehorses
and don’t know any other way of life. When their horses have broken down and
been destroyed, they shrug it off and say “Oh well, one less mouth to feed.”
They’ve hardened themselves and become desensitised to the things that can go
awry with horses. My experience has been that everyone I’ve ever worked with
from shit kicker to top trainer at least liked their horses and most loved them.
We can get attached to them alright. When they go out to gallop and race we
expect that they’ll come back to us uninjured. There are a lot of people who
spend most of their time nurturing, cleaning and feeding thoroughbreds. Often
they do this at ridiculous hours. It’s not for the money. Already sleep-deprived
trainers lie awake at night thinking of better ways to do things.
For the hands on racing participants our world revolves
around the horse. The game is on show every day and it is constantly changing.
With racing being administered by business people who call it a ‘product’, we
desperately need to inject some horsemanship and some humane checks and
balances. Racing needs a code of ethics. I am only aware of one national
horseracing body, the Australian Racing Board (ARB). This organisation, thus far
has been negligent in regards to horse welfare and wastage. In the animal
welfare section of the ARB website, there is no mention of racehorse wastage or
alternatives for owners who would like to spare their horses lives.
According to RIRDC 2006-2011 figures, 40,000 horses are
slaughtered annually. While the report mentions the issue of wastage in the
racing industry, it does not say how many of these horses are thoroughbreds. Any
mention of actual numbers came under the heading of ‘issues raised but not
addressed’. The report also states that there are two registered abattoirs
processing and exporting horsemeat; Peterborough, SA and Caboolture, QLD. As
well as horsemeat exporters, the report states that, ‘there are horse pet meat
knackeries existing in most states of Australia.’
Research and Development Plan 2006-2011 can be viewed on
line (rirdc.gov.au). The research and development plan (R&D) remains unchanged
since its inception in 1995. The reason for this is given in the introduction of
a 26-page printout-
‘The vision and Mission for the R&D Program have
continued to be both inspirational and durable and, following review, are
considered still to serve the Program well. They therefore remain unchanged from
the two previous five year plans.’
In fourteen years (at the time of writing this) and
millions of dollars later, what the 2006-2011 report tells us is that they know
what’s wrong with the racing industry. In regards to the issues of wastage and
breakdown of horses, they seem reluctant to intervene. But they serve their
program well. 80% of their funding for horse R&D comes from the racing industry.
Incidentally, they also mention as a weakness in the horse industry-
- Low level of cohesion between the different sectors
of the horse industry and weak national governance of the horse industry as a
whole
- Industry conservatism and relatively low education
levels and lack of transferable skills in some sectors.
Two unchanged topics noted in their ‘Mission’ from 1995
are;
1. Ensure the health and welfare of the horse.
2. Reduce the current level of wastage.
Hold on to your seats for the next R&D Plan 2012-2017. It
certainly seems ‘durable’ in its current state; they’ll get to have lots more
workshops! Inspirational? Only if increasing sales in horsemeat products
inspires you.
With the microchip being attached to all thoroughbreds
today, every horse could be tracked until its death. Enormous amounts of data
could be collected on the life of racehorses. Information from the horse’s
whereabouts, to health issues, to the life span of the horse’s career could
easily be recorded. This way the industry could make informed decisions on the
welfare of thoroughbreds. Currently, there is no way of knowing the fate of a
horse once it leaves the stud. There is also the issue of accounting for horses
being slaughtered before they are micro chipped. The USA has led the way in this
area. Due to community outrage they have stopped all horses going to the
slaughterhouse. Racing clubs and Jockey’s associations donate to The
Thoroughbred Retirement Foundation. This is just one organisation among many
that tries to find homes for ex-racehorses both privately, in the police force
and even in prison farms. In an innovative approach, caring for animals has
proved therapeutic and rehabilitating for prison inmates. Ultimately two souls
are saved. The UK has organisations devoted to retraining and relocating ex
racers. At least one of these organisations is funded by the British racing
industry. Others too receive sponsorship from the racing industry as well as
from stud farms. Jockeys and individuals both from within the racing industry
and well meaning people elsewhere contribute their expertise and their money to
re-home ex racehorses.
Those with the most at stake - administrators, breeders,
owners and betting agencies - must devise a strategy to stop the wastage of
racehorses. This would need to be done at a national level and be written into
legislation. A national body would seem a logical starting point. I know people
who are put off owning a racehorse because they don’t know what they’d do with
it after its racing career ends. Taking the pressure off babies and implementing
measures to work with difficult horses would increase both quality and longevity
in the life of horses. An extra few weeks spent exposing horses to confined
spaces like barrier stalls early in their education would make a world of
difference. Australia is blessed with a lot of horse people that could help
trainers who are pressed for time. The thoroughbred industry needs to tap into
this network of horsepeople. We should court and work with the numerous people
from other equestrian fields instead of continuously bleating about lack of
competent horse people. Importing labour from overseas has been the racing
industry’s response so far. However, if we are going to attract and keep people
working in the industry, better conditions and incentives are needed.
With a little effort we could greatly change the reality.
We will surely be seen in a different light if we impose some moral standards on
ourselves instead of waiting for the ‘do-gooders’ to step in and then moaning
about them trying to kill our racing off. With open, transparent practices and
goodwill to the real star of the show, horseracing will attract new participants
to our great sport. Potential owners want to be involved with the actual sport
of horseracing, not horsemeat products.
For all of my racing life, we in the Australian racing
industry have been worried about how we are perceived by the general public.
Penalties are quickly dished out to anyone who is deemed to have brought racing
into disrepute. I would argue that we do a pretty good job of it by our daily
practices. Perceptions of the racing industry will change when we do. The
unwanted horse can end up a long way away from where it started. The early
promise not realised often due to our own negligence, we wash our hands of them.
Are we really a nation of horse lovers? At least the ‘dogger bloke’ knows what
he is.
Where in this wide world can man find nobility without
pride,
Friendship without envy,
Or beauty without vanity?
Here, where grace is served with muscle
And strength by gentleness confined
He serves without servility; he has fought without enmity.
There is nothing so powerful, nothing less violent.
There is nothing so quick, nothing more patient.
~Ronald Duncan, "The Horse," 1954
HORSE NEGLECT IN
SABAH 2008:
Photos of Horse neglect in
Sabah, February 2008:
(click on the thumbnails below to
enlarge)
For more information, see:
Dying to be Rescued
Unwanted Horse Coalition
The following information was compiled by HEAL (Humane Ethics for Animal
Life) of Singapore.
HEAL in turn acknowledges the help of various other sources.
Racehorses undergo gruelling training all year
round. When the horses' bodies rebel, symptoms such as bleeding lungs, swollen
joints and tiny cobweb-like bone fractures surface. Sometimes they are hidden by
drugs which can also disguise the presence of other legal and illegal drugs.
Fallacies and Facts
Fallacy 1 - Horses love to gallop and jump. So
horseracing is not cruel because they are just doing something they love anyway.
Horses are naturally endowed with what it takes to be a racehorse.
Fact - Yes, horses can be observed to be
racing with each other in an open paddock but they can stop when they are tired
of it. Race horses cannot stop when tired. If they slow down whips and spurs may
be used. Sometimes there are performance enhancing operations such as the
following which the horses have to go through.
Neurectomy - cutting of the nerves in
the lower leg of a horse with chronic limb pain to reduce sensation.
Firing - the legs of the horses are
burned with hot wires. This is supposed to improve leg tissue and tighten
tendons.
It is also unnatural for a horse to jump over
a fence or large obstacle voluntarily especially with a human on its back at
incredible speed.
Fallacy 2 - Racehorses are not raced unless
they are physically fit enough to withstand the gruelling pace.
Facts-
Immature horses are raced.
Most horses start to be raced when they are as young as two years old.
In an article in AUSTRALIAN THOROUGHBREDS trainer T.J. Hancroft wrote: "Most
well-muscled, well-grown yearlings are skeletally immature ...where the flesh is
willing but the skeleton is weak. Many horses are not mature until 4-5 years of
age". This means that incredible stress is put on the young bones, tendons and
muscles of the young horses.
Overexertion and injury
Overexertion is common. When a horse crashes to the ground, its bones can
explode into a hundred pieces.
Common condition in racehorses - EIPH ( Exercise induced pulmonary haemorrhage)
Often undetected EIPH causes great suffering to the horses which should not be
racing with such a condition.
Lameness
Lameness is a problem that affects a large proportion of horses. Due to extreme
speed, fatigue, immaturity, poor conditioning, poor shoeing etc, fractures of
the carpus are common in thoroughbreds and standard bred horses.
"Therapeutic" Substances
Therapeutic substances (like Phenylbutazone) administered to the horses before
racing can mask the damaging effects of gruelling training, reduce swelling or
tenderness. This enables the horse to race thereby worsening the injury leading
to a more serious breakdown later.
" Horses can come back with chipped knees after a hard race when the bones in
the knees grate and break off. If not removed, the joints can be permanently
damaged".
"Horses are temperate animals, and even if housed in air conditioned stables,
they should not have to run in tropical heat."
Fallacy 3 - The use of the whip during
races is painless and necessary.
Fact - Many races are won without using the
whip. Some horses do not respond to it and others respond by stubbornly slowing
down. Those which increase their speed probably do it out of fear and stress.
Fallacy 4 - A racehorse is turned out to
pasture when its career is over.
Fact - A large number of horses end up in
abattoirs.
What can you do?
Seriously rethink betting in horse races.
Study the subject some more:
HORSERACING IN HONG KONG
AN INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVE
Share your information with your friends and
encourage them to do the same.
Horses are abused in many other ways too.
See:
EQUINE ADVOCATES
EQUINE PROTECTION AND
MANAGEMENT RESEARCH PROJECT
PREMARIN


GREYHOUND RACING

Greyhound Action and the
American European Greyhound Alliance and the ISPCA (Irish Society for the
Prevention of Cruelty to Animals) are all working hard to try to stop the
expansion of greyhound racing to Asia.
The World Greyhound Racing Federation's cranked up publicity machine is working
overtime claiming that in such countries the retired greyhounds will be rehomed
properly. There is a rehoming problem in Western countries with sanctuaries
heaving with abandoned greyhounds. Furthermore as a direct result of racing,
puppies that do not meet racing requirements are routinely killed. Immense
cruelty and death are also inflicted on ex racing dogs as they are no longer
useful to the industry. Imagine the scale of the problem in Asia.
Please see:
Greyhound Action
Greyhound Alliance
PETA on greyhounds
GREY2K USA -
Greyhound Dog Racing Protection
FROM GREYHOUND NETWORK NEWS:
Greyhound racing introduced to Vietnam (from Greyhound Network News)
Racetracks to Spread Throughout Vietnam and into Cambodia
[Editor's Note: The following information from the transcript of a presentation
made by Nguyen Ngoc My at the international conference of the World Greyhound
Racing Federation held in Sydney, Australia, in November 2000.
Nguyen is the general manager of Sports and Entertainment Services (SES), the
company operating the Ba Ria Vung Tau racetrack in Vietnam. Nguyen, who is also
the chairman of Indo China Racing and Entertainment, has been granted a 30-year
license for the development of greyhound racing in Cambodia. A racing facility
has already been identified in Phomn Phenn.The transcript was given to Louise
Coleman, director of Greyhound Friends, Inc., Hopkinton, Mass., while she was in
Dublin attending the International Greyhound Welfare Forum in February. The
semi-annual meetings are chaired by the London-based National Canine Defence
League.] Greyhound racing commenced May 5, 2000 with an eight-race program. All
races were eight dog fields over 450 meters (M). Race meetings were held once a
week until mid-July when one distance race of 630 M per week was added.
Beginning in mid-August, flying races of 260 M were introduced [no definition
given] in conjunction with adding a second race meeting per week. The track is a
tight two-turn circuit of 393 M. Dogs race in three distances: 260 M, 450 M, and
630 M. Betting turnover increased exponentially during the formative period. In
less than eight weeks betting turnover grew by more than 100 per cent. Average
attendance at Saturday race meetings is 3,500 to 4,000. There are six kennel
blocks, each holding 38 greyhounds; three isolation blocks contain eight kennels
used for quarantine purposes, and for sick and/or injured dogs. SES has begun a
breeding program to supplement the need to import racing greyhounds. The program
is expected to be fully effective within two years. Public ownership of
greyhounds will be introduced in 2001. The greyhounds will be kept at Ba Ria and
trained by SES trainers. The owners will pay a monthly training fee and receive
prize money. SES plans to develop six more dog tracks throughout Vietnam. Other
planned locations are Ho Chi Minh City, Hanoi, Hai Phong, Da Nang, Nha Trang,
and Can Tho. In his conclusion, Nguyen said, " I am pleased to report that the
local Vietnamese have embraced greyhound racing with similar passion to that of
other countries which host the sport. It is therefore timely to move on and
continue to develop a network of greyhound tracks throughout Vietnam." For
continued updates on the developing Vietnam situation, visit
www.ameurogreyhoundalliance.org
Please write letters of protest to the following selected Vietnam Embassies
urging them to stop greyhound racing in Vietnam
USA
Ambassador Le Van Bang
1233 20th street
N.W.Suite 501
Washington DC 2003
UK
12-14 Victoria rd
London .W8RD
0207 937 1912
United States Liaison Office in Vietnam
7 Lang Ha, st, Hanoi, Vietnam
350445431301
Chamber of Commerce and Industry
Head office
Chamber of Commerce and Industry
Secretary General: Mdm Pham Chi lan
International Relations Department
33a Ba Trieu Str.Hanoi, Vietnam
844-253023
Vung Tua City
Chamber of Commerce and Industry
Director: Mr. Vo Van Cao
36/6, Vo Thi Sau str, Vangtua City, Vietnam
846-482710
YOU BET THEY DIE - Support the campaign against greyhound racing!
All the information below is either based on figures produced by the greyhound
industry itself or on statements made by individuals who have worked either in
the industry or in greyhound rescue.
Tens of thousands of greyhounds are disposed of every year by the greyhound
racing industry, either because they fail to make the grade as racers or because
their racing days are over.
At least 40,000 greyhounds are bred every year in Great Britain and Ireland. The
majority of these dogs are produced to supply the demand of the British
greyhound racing industry, which is the biggest in the world. Thousands of
greyhound pups and young dogs are put to death because they fail to reach racing
standards. We estimate that as many as 20,000 are killed annually in Ireland and
about 4,000 in Britain. Dogs which actually make it to the track are very likely
to experience suffering during their racing careers. It has been estimated that
greyhounds running on British tracks sustain more than 12,000 injuries every
year and that 10% of dogs that race are already suffering from injuries. Injured
toes, torn muscles, strained tendons and arthritic joints are commonplace. At
least 10,000 greyhounds "retire" from racing in Britain every year, at an
average age of just 2½ years old. This is either because of injury or because
they are adjudged to be no longer good enough to continue racing. Very few of
these dogs manage to find good homes. This is hardly surprising, given a
situation where tens of thousands of ordinary dogs are put to sleep every year
because no homes are available for them. The British Greyhound Racing Board
itself admits that 500 retired greyhounds are put to death every year. This
alone would be enough to justify a ban on greyhound racing, but the true figure
for dogs killed is, sadly, far, far higher. Many ex-racing greyhounds are simply
abandoned and a large number are killed, sometimes by extremely cruel methods
such as drowning or poisoning, because some owners and trainers are not prepared
to pay the cost of having them put to sleep by a vet. Greyhounds have been found
mutilated with their ears chopped off to prevent the ear tattoo, mark of
registration being traced back to the owner. We are also receiving an
increasing number of reports of trainers shooting dogs in the head or the heart
when their racing days are over.
Every year many hundreds of "unwanted" greyhounds are shipped to Spain to be
kept for racing in appalling conditions or used for hunting and coursing. Dogs
which turn out to be no good for hunting are often brutally disposed of, with
hanging being a favourite method. The WGRF (World Greyhound Racing Federation)
racing's governing body has begun to expand greyhound racing to Asia, countries
such as Vietnam, Korea, Indo China, Cambodia and the Philippines. These
countries are notorious for killing dogs for human consumption using cruel
methods such as hanging the dogs by the throat and skinning them then using a
blow torch they roast them. The same fate is facing the greyhounds.
The only way to prevent the massive suffering and deaths of greyhounds caused by
the greyhound racing industry is for greyhound racing to be abolished. It is
interesting to note that this has already happened in the USA, where six states
have banned greyhound racing since 1993. In the meantime it is important that
people avoid attending or betting on greyhound racing, so that it gradually
comes to an end through lack of finance and support.
GREYHOUND ACTION
Greyhound Action was formed in 1997 with the ultimate aim of putting an end to
greyhound racing. There are several other groups which are dedicated to finding
homes for ex-racing greyhounds, but in practical terms it is only possible to
re-home a very small percentage of the vast number of greyhounds disposed of
every year by the greyhound racing industry. Therefore the total abolition of
greyhound racing is the only real solution. Greyhound Action is seeking to
educate the public about the dark side of greyhound racing, so that support for
this so-called "sport" withers away. We are also attempting to put pressure on
the government to ban greyhound racing altogether. We know it will take a long
battle to achieve such a ban, but it is not an impossible aim, as the abolition
of dog racing in several American states has shown. As part of our campaign a
petition calling for a ban on greyhound racing has been produced, as well as
leaflets, posters, badges and stickers.
HOW YOU CAN HELP
By doing whatever you can to educate the public not to support greyhound racing.
This can be done through street stalls, writing letters to newspapers and doing
interviews in the local media. Demonstrations can beheld outside greyhound
tracks and leaflets distributed to those attending greyhound races and betting
shops. If you would like to do any of the above, please let us know and we will
send you whatever information and campaign materials you require. Greyhound
Action, PO Box 127, Kidderminster, DY10 3UZTel: 01562 745778, Mobile: 07703
558724, Fax: 0870 138 3993, E-mail:
greyhoundaction@blueyonder.co.uk
The programme on BBC1 on the 6th DEC 'Kenyon Confronts' exposed the greyhound
industry. They uncovered race fixing proving no one can win on the dogs. They
showed horrendous cruelty inflicted on greyhounds including dog doping using
dangerous illegal drugs such as cocaine which if the dog can survive they will
suffer from long term health problems.
Also exposed is trainer called Steve Davis who shoots dogs and buries them
in a mass grave. This trainer is still racing his dogs at Swindon race tracks.
He has around 200 dogs at his kennels, he is one of many trainers that commit
the same acts of cruelty.
Click the greyhound:

Animals Asia Foundation Report
Greyhound Racing Industry in Vietnam
2nd November 2002
AAF - Vietnam Background
Animals Asia investigators have been visiting Vietnam since 1999.
Vietnam currently has no animal welfare legislation. Animal
welfare
issues documented by Animals Asia in Vietnam are the illegal trade in
wildlife, the illegal farming of Asiatic black bears for bile, and the
slaughter and consumption of dogs.
Dog eating is mainly prevalent in the north of Vietnam. Hanoi has
a
street dedicated to dog meat restaurants. However dog meat stalls
had
been previously witnessed in the south, in Ho Chi Minh City.
Greyhound Industry in Vietnam
Ba Ria Vung Tau Tourist Corporation in a joint venture with an Australian
Company Hemlock Services, have established Sports & Entertainment Services
Co Ltd (SES). SES has established the greyhound racing industry in
Vietnam. They built Lam Son Stadium in Vung Tau and a greyhound
breeding/training facility in nearby Ba Ria.
Vung Tau City is a popular beachside resort, 2 ½ hours drive from Ho Chi
Minh City.
Posters promote greyhound racing in hotels in Vung Tau and one advertising
billboard was observed. Racing is conducted on Saturday nights between 7
pm and 10 pm.
Animals Asia was made aware of a report by Cyndi Napolitan from November
2001. This report and photos were viewed by many with a degree of
scepticism. Some doubt has been expressed as to whether this article and
photographs were a
true indication of the day-to-day running of the new facility.
As a result of concerns expressed by the International Greyhound Alliance,
and Animals Australia (ANZFAS) at the exportation of greyhounds from
Australia to Vietnam, Animals Asia investigators visited Vung Tau on the
2nd November 2002.
Visit to Greyhound breeding facility - Ba Ria
Saturday 2nd November 2002
After unsuccessfully trying to arrange a formal visit through a local
contact, an unannounced visit was made to this facility with a Vietnamese
interpreter. The breeding/training facility is located in
the township
of Ba Ria about 30 kilometres from Vung Tau City.
The facility covers many hectares. A high perimeter fence and
front
gates secure it. Two Vietnamese staff monitor the entrance.
My interpreter conveyed that I was visiting from Australia and was
interested in greyhound racing. The attendant rode off on his pushbike
to
convey my request to management and returned and opened the gates to allow
our vehicle to drive to the facility.
Driving to the office complex I observed greyhounds being walked on leads
around a large lake.
I also observed a greyhound being exercised on a lead in a single lane
25-metre swimming pool.
I was met by and received a warm welcome from Mr Hai - the
assistant
manager. Mr Hai speaks perfect English and is well educated.
He is an
Australian Vietnamese. The overall manager is also Vietnamese, Mr
Nguyen
and is based in Australia.
Mr Hai introduced me to Mr Ngoc, the kennel manager. Mr Ngoc also
speaks
perfect English. He had spent 15 years in Australia. He was
also very
friendly and welcoming.
I spent the next 45 minutes with Mr Ngoc - who showed me all areas of
the
facility, and willingly responded to my questions.
My overall observations confirmed that the images displayed at
http://www.globalgreyhounds.com/vietnam/vietnam.htm accurately depict this
facility. It is obvious that no expense was spared in its
creation. The
welfare and physical health of the dogs appears to have been given serious
consideration.
Staff were observed displaying affection towards the dogs, and the dogs
were obviously happy in their presence. The individual long kennel
compounds house approximately 30 dogs and each has four permanent staff
assigned to care for the dogs. Dogs all have canvas sack beds
imported
from Australia, runs were clean, had an indoor and outdoor area and all
had fresh water. A water spray system is available on hot days to
dogs
in the outdoor section.
There are currently have four hundred greyhounds on site. Two
hundred
and forty dogs were originally brought from Australia and New Zealand in
1999. The intention is to continue breeding Greyhounds in
Vietnam and
not import further greyhounds. Currently in Vung Tau they are restricted
to racing once a week due to available dogs - and intentions are
also to
expand the industry into other areas of Vietnam.
All dogs on site are owned by SES Corporation - dogs cannot
be
privately owned. The long term goal is to have a greyhound track
in
every city in Vietnam. Currently they have submitted an
application to
the Vietnam government to create their second track/stadium in Hai Phong.
There are 50 permanent staff at this facility - many who
live on
site. There are 3 permanent Veterinary surgeons, one Australian
trained,
and two locally trained.
Information provided by Mr Ngoc is that the oldest dogs bred on the
facility are now 15 months old. Litters bred remain together
in group
housing until 11 months old - and have a permanent large exercise run.
At 11 months old racing training commences. Dogs are first raced at 15
months old.
Dogs are raced for 3 weeks and then have the 4th week off. There
are 10
races on Saturday nights - 8 dogs per race. Decisions
as to placement
of dogs in races are made by SES head office in HCM City depending on the
results of the previous week, injuries, and dogs being rested.
All individually kennelled dogs that do not have access to exercise runs
are walked for 4 kms each morning around the lake.
I observed kennelled dog areas, the group housing of young dogs, and 3
bitches with pups separately housed.
I was shown the large kitchen compound where food was being prepared for
the evening feed. The kitchen was well organised and spotlessly
clean.
All dog dinners were being prepared in stainless steel bowls. The
dogs
are fed on a premium brand Canadian dry dog food (it would appear that
they are part sponsors from signage at stadium) and kangaroo meat,
imported by the container load from Australia. Food is stored in a
large
freezer room.
Whilst not an expert in this area - my observations of the on site
veterinary hospital was that it is extremely well equipped, and again, was
spotlessly clean. This area contains offices for the vets, a large
examination and treatment room, a separate operating theatre, and a large
and well stocked drug room. All records relevant to individual dogs are
kept on file. I met two of the vets who were entering data onto computer
records. All dogs are microchipped.
Racing - Lam Son Stadium
Dogs are conveyed to the racetrack on Saturday evenings in individual
cages on a large air-conditioned bus
By any country's standards the Lam Son stadium is impressive. On
this
particular night there was 2 to 3 thousand people in attendance.
In
holiday season there can be 7 to 8 thousand people. Many people
seemed
just to be spectating - few seemed to be placing bets.
The racing is
videoed and played on close circuit TV monitors around the stadium -
betting odds are displayed on these same monitors.
The cost of entrance to the stadium is 10,000 VND for general areas,
20,000 VND for the grandstand and 50,000 VND for the VIP air-conditioned
enclosed viewing area.
(US $1 = 15,325 VND)
In a preparation area dogs are allowed to stretch etc prior to races and
are microchip scanned. Dogs then have their numbers tied on and are
paraded in front of the crowd on 3 occasions before a race. All
aspects
of this handling, plus the placing of dogs in the starting gates, were
being performed with care.
However, it was disturbing to observe one particular Greyhound exhibiting
obvious fear and an unwillingness to be part of proceedings. When placed
in the starting box he repeatedly barked in distress and scratched at the
door. He performed poorly in the race.
Dogs were washed down after races and rubbed dry with towels.
I
observed that the two vets that I had met at the breeding facility were
both at the racetrack.
Officials with hand held radios were controlling timing of activities and
races.
Fate of unwanted Greyhounds
Aside from ascertaining the level of care and well being of the dogs -
a
priority was to assess the likelihood of Greyhounds ending up in the food
trade.
I spoke with Kennel manager Mr Ngoc about this issue.
I was advised that dogs are raced to the age of 5 years old.
Mr Ngoc's response to my query as to what happened to the dogs once their
racing life was complete - was that they try to find good homes
for
them, and if they can't they are euthanised by injection.
I was
informed that dogs made available for adoption are all spayed -
"because we don't want to cause a problem by having greyhounds
everywhere".
On face value - it would seem to be done purely
through a sense of
responsibility, and this may be the case. However, it
could be
suggested that this measure also ensures that SES maintains total control
of this fledgling industry in Vietnam.
Based on local knowledge in Vietnam, and information gained as a result of
this investigation, I feel that there is minimal possibility of Greyhounds
ending up in the dog meat trade.
My reasons are as follows:
1/ From my observation - every aspect of SES's operations from the
breeding facility to building of Lam Son Stadium have been created with
total professionalism. One might even suggest that the extremes of
care
taken in every aspect of this new industry in Vietnam, may well be as a
result of being aware that establishing such an industry in a dog eating
country would face criticism.
In what is obviously a multimillion-dollar investment for SES it is
difficult to imagine that they would place the reputation at risk by
selling off unwanted Greyhounds for what would amount to a few dollars.
2/ Vung Tau City does have one dog meat restaurant. However there is a
preference for young dogs in Vietnam, and there is no shortage of young
dogs to meet current needs whether in Vung Tau, or in other areas of
Vietnam. In those areas where dog eating is predominant, it is common
for
families to keep one dog as a pet and then sell the puppies to restaurants
or keep for personal consumption.
My observations of the Vung Tau dog restaurant and dogs that had met
their fate, or were waiting to - was that they were serving young
dogs. Ironically premises on both sides of the restaurant were
observed
to have well fed and seemingly contented dogs interacting with their
owners. On a practical level, greyhounds because of their age and
lithe
physical appearance may not be attractive to dog meat vendors' even if
made available. Also it would seem that Greyhounds are being
afforded a
level of respect not given to local dogs, through being involved in an
industry that in Vietnam is seen as unique and exciting.
3/ Perhaps the most positive aspect witnessed both at the
breeding/training facility and also at the racetrack was the interaction
and relationship between the staff and the dogs. The system
established
by the breeding centre ensures a degree of one to one care on a daily
basis. Staff showing affection to dogs was witnessed on a number of
occasions. This bond with day to day staff, combined with
the fact that
the management of this facility are Vietnamese that have been educated
overseas, and have spent considerable time in western countries -
would
also decrease the likelihood of Greyhounds ending up at restaurants.
Summary
The Animals Asia Foundation is opposed to Greyhound Racing in any country.
Greater concerns had been raised for Greyhounds in Vietnam due to the lack
of animal welfare legislation, and in the knowledge that some members of
Vietnamese society consume dogs as a food source.
My visit to the breeding/training facility at Ba Ria was unannounced,
therefore allaying concerns that it may be "tidied" up in preparation.
My
overall assessment of this facility is that it is professionally run, and
the standard of care and housing is high. In Vietnam, such a
facility,
and level of care of animals, is unprecedented.
The undisputed negative factors remain, that these animals are being
exploited for commercial gain, local people through this industry are
being exploited through being encouraged to gamble, and regardless of the
minimal prospect that Greyhounds will end up as a food source, the reality
remains that more dogs will be euthanised than find good homes, once they
have outlived their usefulness.
Lyn White
Regional Director (Aus/NZ) /Vietnam Representative
Animals Asia Foundation
On to Hunting.
Last revised:
18-Jul-10
|